Home › Compare

Birmingham vs New York: which is cheaper?

Birmingham is 23% cheaperBased on official 2024 price levels from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis.

I need $73,696 in New York to live the same way.

🏠 Rent per month
$1,291
$2,806
🛏️ 2-bedroom rent
$1,126
$2,016
💵 Families earn per year
$49,666
$86,801
🔑 Buying a house
$158,800
$777,600
📊 Overall prices (U.S. = 100)
91.6
112.6
🏛️ Property tax per year
$997
$6,547
⚡ Electric bill per month
$175
$132
👥 People living there
198,173
8,483,844
Commute to work
20.8 min
40.3 min
College degree
31.1%
41.6%
Own their home
45.5%
32.8%
Below poverty line
24.7%
17.9%
Unemployment
5.8%
8%

Bottom line

Pay for the same job

JobBirminghamNew YorkDifference
Firefighter$51,050$106,420+108% in New York
Dental Hygienist$61,730$109,720+78% in New York
Police Officer$60,590$105,540+74% in New York
Server (Waiter/Waitress)$27,670$47,610+72% in New York
Market Research Analyst$62,190$100,520+62% in New York
HVAC Technician$48,740$77,990+60% in New York
Physician Assistant$105,440$167,650+59% in New York
Elementary School Teacher$62,630$96,900+55% in New York

Frequently asked questions

Is Birmingham or New York cheaper to live in?

Birmingham is about 23% cheaper overall. Rent is $1,291 a month there versus $2,806 in New York.

What salary do I need in New York to match $60,000 in Birmingham?

About $73,696 a year gives the same standard of living in New York.

Where do people earn more, Birmingham or New York?

The typical household earns $49,666 in Birmingham and $86,801 in New York, 43% more in New York.

More comparisons

All Birmingham comparisons → · All New York comparisons →

Birmingham vs Grand RapidsBirmingham vs MontgomeryBirmingham vs PeoriaBirmingham vs Sunrise ManorBirmingham vs Overland ParkBirmingham vs OxnardNew York vs Los AngelesNew York vs ChicagoNew York vs HoustonNew York vs PhoenixNew York vs PhiladelphiaNew York vs San Antonio